HMRC must reconsider refusing a concession

HMRC must reconsider refusing a concession

Case at a glance · Excise duty
Court
Court of Appeal
Reference
Judicial review
Decided
November 2026
At stake
Amusement machine licence duty, 2004–06
OutcomeAppeal allowed: HMRC must reconsider its refusal to apply the concession.

Background

This long-running dispute concerned under-declared amusement machine licence duty on slot machines in bingo halls and arcades between 2004 and 2006. A group of operators asked HMRC to apply two extra-statutory concessions: one for under-declarations caused by a genuine misunderstanding, and one for cases where HMRC had misdirected the taxpayer.

HMRC refused, and in July 2025 the High Court dismissed the operators’ judicial review.

The decision

The Court of Appeal has allowed their appeal on the misunderstanding concession. It found that the reasons HMRC gave for refusing it were flawed, so HMRC must now reconsider. Having decided that, the court did not need to rule on the misdirection concession.

Our view

HMRC’s decisions on concessions and other discretionary reliefs can be challenged by judicial review if they are not properly reasoned. Where a client has been refused a concession, it is worth checking the reasons HMRC gave.

Please note: this is a recent decision and HMRC may seek permission to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Could this affect you or your business?

Talk to our tax team about what this decision means for your situation.

Book an appointment

This article is general information for clients and is not advice on any specific situation. Please contact us before acting on any of the matters above.