Protecting EIS relief is not an income tax advantage

Protecting EIS relief is not an income tax advantage

Case at a glance · Income tax
Court
Court of Appeal
Reference
[2026] EWCA Civ 1440
Decided
12 November 2026
At stake
£20m of buyback proceeds
OutcomeHMRC’s appeal dismissed: the transactions in securities rules did not apply.

Background

In March 2015, two entrepreneurs sold EIS shares back to the company for £11 million and £9 million respectively, treating the proceeds as capital covered by EIS disposal relief. In 2021 HMRC issued counteraction notices under the transactions in securities (TiS) rules in ITA 2007, arguing that the buybacks were designed to obtain an income tax advantage.

The decision

The First-tier Tribunal found for HMRC. The Upper Tribunal reversed that decision, and the Court of Appeal has now unanimously dismissed HMRC’s appeal.

Having a main purpose of securing EIS capital gains tax relief does not, without more, amount to a main purpose of obtaining an income tax advantage. The court distinguished the purpose of a transaction from its inevitable tax effect.

Our view

This is a welcome result for founders and investors using buybacks. The TiS rules remain wide, though, and we still recommend applying for HMRC clearance before any share buyback or capital return from a close company.

Please note: this is a recent decision and HMRC may seek permission to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Could this affect you or your business?

Talk to our tax team about what this decision means for your situation.

Book an appointment

This article is general information for clients and is not advice on any specific situation. Please contact us before acting on any of the matters above.