
Pool house was not a separate dwelling for multiple dwellings relief
Background
The buyer of a £2.6 million country house in Kent claimed multiple dwellings relief (MDR) for SDLT on the basis that a pool house in the grounds was a separate dwelling. The pool house had its own kitchen, shower and drive. The claim was worth £80,750.
The decision
The First-tier Tribunal held that the pool house was not suitable for use as a single dwelling. The arrangement failed on privacy and security, because sharing the pool would realistically mean the main house occupants using the pool house’s shower and toilet. A main house that gave up access to the pool was not a realistic arrangement either.
MDR was abolished for transactions completing on or after 1 June 2024, but many earlier claims and HMRC enquiries are still open. Tribunals continue to test annexes and outbuildings strictly on privacy, security and independence. Clients with a pending MDR claim should check it against these recent decisions.
Please note: this is a recent decision and may be subject to appeal.
Talk to our tax team about what this decision means for your situation.
Book an appointmentThis article is general information for clients and is not advice on any specific situation. Please contact us before acting on any of the matters above.
