
Director personally liable for £12.8m of VAT fraud penalties
Background
The sole director of a company trading in mobile phones, computer equipment and other electronic goods appealed against a personal liability notice. HMRC had concluded that the company’s deals formed part of supply chains connected with Missing Trader Intra-Community (MTIC) fraud, and the notice made the director liable for penalties of roughly £12.8 million.
The director argued that he did not know, and could not reasonably have known, that the transactions were connected with fraud. He said the company had carried out commercial checks and due diligence, and that the evidence did not show he was involved in fraudulent trading. HMRC pointed to repeated warnings it had given him about the supply chains and its suspicions. Despite those warnings, the company kept trading.
The decision
The First-tier Tribunal dismissed the appeal. It found that the director knew the transactions were connected with VAT evasion and that the inaccuracies in the company’s VAT returns were deliberate. HMRC’s decision was upheld, leaving him personally liable for penalties of about £12.8 million.
Once HMRC has warned a business about MTIC risk in its supply chains, carrying on trading through the same kind of chains is very hard to defend, and due diligence that exists only on paper will not help. The Upper Tribunal took a similar line in July 2026 ([2026] UKUT 275 (TCC)), where the sole director of a labour supply business was held personally liable for more than £900,000 because the company should have known of fraud in its payroll supply chain. Directors in high-risk sectors such as electronics, labour supply and metals should act on any HMRC warning letter straight away and take advice.
Please note: this is a recent decision and may be subject to appeal.
Talk to our tax team about what this decision means for your situation.
Book an appointmentThis article is general information for clients and is not advice on any specific situation. Please contact us before acting on any of the matters above.
