
Outsourcing your payroll does not outsource your employees
Background
A company in the wind energy sector had between 20 and 30 workers. In 2019 it stopped running payroll in-house and used two outside payroll companies in turn. Those companies invoiced it for the workers’ wages and employer’s National Insurance, plus VAT on the full amount, and the company reclaimed that VAT as input tax.
HMRC assessed £569,175, covering June 2019 and September 2019 to March 2022. The company argued that the workers had transferred to the payroll companies, which then supplied the staff back to it, so the VAT was recoverable on a taxable supply of staff.
The decision
The First-tier Tribunal disagreed. On the facts, the workers stayed employed by the company throughout. The only taxable supply it received was payroll administration, so the VAT charged on the wages and NIC element was not input tax it could recover.
VAT shown on an invoice is not automatically recoverable. Tribunals look at the substance: who employs the workers, who controls them, and what the contracts actually say. A normal payroll bureau charges VAT only on its fee. Be very wary of any arrangement that puts VAT on the whole wage bill.
Please note: this is a recent decision and may be subject to appeal.
Talk to our tax team about what this decision means for your situation.
Book an appointmentThis article is general information for clients and is not advice on any specific situation. Please contact us before acting on any of the matters above.
